GAY MARRIAGE CHALLENGE UPDATE
I will write a response to the comments in the original post below, some time in the next day or so. I had intended to do it this weekend, but real life has intruded. Hopefully it is nothing serious, but a thing or two have kept me from being able to focus and do justice to the topic. Suffice it to say that I'm happy the comments thus far have remained civil. Gay marriage is and will for a long time be a wrenching issue--watch the unfolding turmoil in Canada and the Episcopal church if you don't believe me. But hopefully thoughtful people can discuss it without resorting to gutter tactics. So far everyone here has.
MORE: I think this Maggie Gallagher quote says it all--
The problem with endorsing gay marriage is not that it would allow a handful of people to choose alternative family forms, but that it would require society at large to gut marriage of its central presumptions about family in order to accommodate a few adults' desires.
Her entire article is a must-read.











