Now Playing on JYB Films

Anatomy of the Comic Jihad


Movie File Host
YouTube YouTube
Putfile Putfile


Movie File Host
YouTube

The Meaning of Taqiyya







button02b
fpawbn
July 2008
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    
$1 Shipping for 4 days, only at Overstock.com!
button
Recent Comments
Archives

Content Staff
Technical Staff
credit where due
This site is still alive and kicking thanks to the generosity and talents of Alan M. Carroll (aka Annoying Old Guy). Without him, the JYB would still be suffering with Blogger's bad code and long-term archive loss.
Powered by
Hosted By
Anti-Junk: 570 sources banned.

Brian Williams' Nightmares

In a speech to New York University journalism students, NBC Evening News anchor Brian Williams warned them of the future that awaits them in the field: “You’re going to be up against people who have an opinion, a modem, and a bathrobe. All of my life, developing credentials to cover my field of work, and now I’m up against a guy named Vinny in an efficiency apartment in the Bronx who hasn’t left the efficiency apartment in two years.”
Sorry Brian, but though he may need a vacation, Allahpundit lives in Queens.

JYB Tailwag to Don Surber, who I'm going to have to add to my favorites bar.

UPDATE: Good comments so far, esp. a long one from Redherkey, which includes the following:

Now that first-handers (business executives, economists, scientists, technologists, politicians, etc.) can replicate the functionality of a newspaper with a few clicks of a mouse in a blog subscription, superior information from first-handers makes the diluted content from journalists unnecessary. And given the proclivity of journalists to now slant and misrepresent the content, they shouldn’t be terribly surprised that their profession will likely cease to exist in less than a dozen years.

Certainly, the need for news aggregation will continue. However, it is something software is already facilitating.


Brian's competition isn't Vinny in the bathrobe; it's the professor in his lab who doesn't trust NBC to represent his position clearly so he just writes it up himself and puts it on the web.

Post to del.icio.us

Posted by SeeDubya on April 13, 2007 4:06 PM
Trackbacks: View (0)Ping
Comments

It’s amusing how “professionals” who took relatively easy courses in news writing, editing and reporting consider themselves as experts in most fields, yet those of us who studied calc, quantitative methods, econometrics, forecasting and such aren’t qualified to make public commentary in our area of expertise.

As a risk econometrician who spent two years as a journalism major and interned in a major metro paper, I switched degree paths once I discovered the lack of substance and the serious absence of ethics in journalism. Doctored quotes are the norm, false confidence about a subject matter typical, and intended slant expected.

What Williams and his underqualified peers should understand is that their profession only existed when there was an economic incentive for the centralization of information collection and dissemination (e.g. newspapers and television stations requiring significant capital). This environment permitted “news collectors” to emerge as a quasi-professional class and facilitated the rise of information second-handers as a dominant form. Pretty faces with deep voices became self-declared experts, giving rise to an entire class of high self-esteem individuals like Dan Rather who lacked any material qualifications.

Now that first-handers (business executives, economists, scientists, technologists, politicians, etc.) can replicate the functionality of a newspaper with a few clicks of a mouse in a blog subscription, superior information from first-handers makes the diluted content from journalists unnecessary. And given the proclivity of journalists to now slant and misrepresent the content, they shouldn’t be terribly surprised that their profession will likely cease to exist in less than a dozen years.

Certainly, the need for news aggregation will continue. However, it is something software is already facilitating. For news stories requiring a human touch, low-cost news editing functionality is already available and utilized in nations like India, China and South Korea. The era of puffed up pretty news readers and chain-smoking angry newswriters is over.

Posted by redherkey on April 14, 2007 6:55 AM

It’s interesting that the market is so large for repackaging and interpretation of news stories. It appears that the market is hungry for something that journalists don’t provide.

Geez, doesn’t it sound like Brian Williams feels threatened by the blogsphere?

Memo to Mr. Williams - ordinary people are looking for the truth, not your interpretation of what the truth is. You’re a dinosaur, and if the press does not clean up its act, you’ll go the same way they did.

Posted by fmfnavydoc on April 14, 2007 12:00 PM
Post a comment